We ate a lunch and a dinner at the Mayflower. I had the fish both times and it was good. The Portuguese Fish and Chips was good when I had it...as was the fish sandwich. It wasn't what I would call the best dining experience ever, but the staff was friendly and I would go there again.

I'm not sure that this can possibly be the #1 restaurant in Provincetown and I feel bad for the other restaurants in the area that put more thought into their food and atmosphere. Food was decent, but yes, very much a diner experience. Nothing special about the place.

As others have noted, this is a diner-like, chain-food type of dining experience. Like the Lobster Pot, it's a place for tourists, but the Pot has outstanding food. My niece failed to call me before eating here. She ordered lobster bisque soup then lobster ravioli. She said it was the same sauce for the soup as on the pasta. If you like Friendly's, you'll like the Mayflower.

Vegetarian visitor that ended up hungry at the end of the girls night in P-town. This place is cheap. So cheap they served me mixed frozen vegetables as side dish and the rice pilaf was nothing more than oil-laden white rice. The waitstaff doesn't even say pardon me as they reach over your food to pour beverages. Maybe I expect alot...but I thought P-town would have more to offer than this. Next time I'll try the international menu when visiting. It is the 21 century...right? vegetarians are not taboo as being gay isn't taboo in P-town. Mayflower, you are indesperate need of a menu overhaul.