The Mayflower Cafe is a historical treasure set smack dab in the middle of all the 'action' P'Town has to offer. It is a welcome oasis from all the chi-chi, pretentious and overpriced joints that line Commercial Street. It is not snobby, elitist or precious. It is welcoming to all, serves great food and at very reasonable prices. Presentation is basic (fine by me). I prefer this simple approach. It is a welcome alternative to the popular trend of being served a miniscule portion, stacked vertically and manhandled by all the kitchen staff for the sake of a ostentatious presentation.
I have been visiting Cape Cod and P'town since the early 1970's. Much has changed over the years, but I can count on the Mayflower. The fact that a restaurant has been in existance since 1929 is a miracle in itself but even more so in Provincetown.
Over the years I have sampled the dinners, sandwiches, soup etc. (all good) but lately my favorite is a meal I made up myself off their menu: the stuffed clam appetizer (huge and great) and a side of their wonderful spaghetti (great sauce). This is plenty for me. My husband usually adds a bowl of Portugese Kale soup to the above.
Anyway, if you are in Provincetown and want good food in a friendly atmosphere, in a historical setting, that won't break the bank , I highly recommend the Mayflower Cafe.
No snobs allowed!

Most reasonable prices in town if you're trying to feed the family without breaking the bank. We ate there twice, had lobster rolls and clam chowder one night, both very good, then had eggplant parmesan, also very good. Very fast service, we never waited long for anything.

the staff are very nice.

the food is basic diner stuff. My 7 year old complained his grilled cheese was too bland. It's all about white bread, margerine and plastic cups for beverages. If that's all you want, you'll be happy.

Provincetown resturants can be pricey. The Mayflower, which is family run, has good, home-cooked style food at moderate prices. The atmosphere is warm and friendly. I go there with my friends and am never disappointed.