My boyfriend and I ate at Sarabeth's twice while we were in Key West. The restaurant was highly recommended by the staff at our hotel so we decided to give it a try. Our first visit was dinner on a beautiful August evening. Dave, the owner and one of the friendliest faces in the entire town, greeted us at the door and lead us to a candlelit table on front patio. We ordered the Mahi and the Roasted Chicken and found both dishes to be fantastic (A+). The meal was topped off by a slice of Key Lime Cream Pie and a cup of coffee. We loved the food and the owner so much we decided to go back the very next day for breakfast. Our choice for breakfast was determined by the dish we saw being delivered to our neighbor's table. I couldn't help but notice the gorgeous stack of fully pancakes with fresh strawberries tucked in between. My boyfriend and I both ordered the that very same dish - Lemon Ricotta Pancakes - and we were both in agreement, this was the MOST DELICIOUS pancake we had ever eaten (A+++). The only negative thing I could say about the meal was that I could not finish all five pancakes.

I cannot wait until our next trip to Key West just so I can visit Sarabeth's.

We have our Key West favorites and had never been to Sarabeth's. We decided to give it a try for lunch, and are sure glad we did. Outdoor patio is a great place to sit. We had fresh lemonade to keep us cool. I had the smoked mozarella sandwich that was unbelieveable; along with a delicious slaw. My wife had the grouper sandwich with hot, fresh fries. It was an unexpected treat...we'll try for breakfast next trip.

We were excited to go to Sarabeth's after reading the great breakfast reviews, so we decided to walk there from our hotel. We walked a mile only to be disappointed. My husband had the pink shrimp omelet which was under-done. His side dish of home fries/potatoes was cold. We told the waitress that the potatoes were cold, so she left to get us some more. She returned later and said that the pototoes were now done and did we still want them? (by that time, we were done with the rest of the food) I had the salmon and cream cheese eggs which were good but not that hot. Overall we were disappointed and would not eat there again. There are just too many good restaurants to try to waste your time on mediocrity!

During a family weekend in Key West, we went to Sarabeth's for breakfast based on TA reviews. The concierge at our hotel tried to sway us away from it, but we went ahead anyway.

Loved the food; between the four of us, the winner was the Lemon Ricotta pancakes. We sat outside, on a very nice patio that exemplifies Key West. The location was good, not too far from the major hotels, but away from the Duval touristy ambiance. The owner David greeted us, and checked on us several, several times. He seemed like a perfectionist that wanted to make sure everything was to his standards.

Don't miss Sarabeth's and the pancakes on your next visit to Key West ...