My wife (who is subject to motion sickness) and I went out with Eagle Wing this week, and it was wonderful! We originally booked a trip on their larger boat, which was nearly empty at the time; they were very up-front about the fact that the trip might not go (they want about 40-50% capacity before sending a boat, which is reasonable, as the capacities are quite low). (Though their morning trips seemed to generally be full during our trip, afternoons had many openings.) They did eventually cancel that tour, but we took space on their smaller boat for the sunset tour.
Although it is still a speed boat, and somewhat rough for some individuals (pregnant women, very small children, those with physical handicaps), the smaller boat still was much better than the Zodiac boats everyone else runs. The smaller boats do have much more range than the large covered boats (we had to chase the whales a long way; those in large boats got 20-30 minutes of viewing time, while we had 1.5 hours). The Eagle Wing boats are faster and much smoother than the Zodiacs; coming back in when the tide had turned and wind was against us, the trip was somewhat rough, but we remained dry and only slightly uncomfortable; the zodiacs we passed were bouncing almost completely out of the water and everyone was completely soaked. (They were wearing complete survival suits; we were wearing optional marine jackets for the wind.) Moreover, our driver Dave handled the trip in extremely well despite the rough conditions, definitely one of the best drivers available. He even remembered to stop on the way back when he found a bald eagle, as one of the other passengers mentioned in passing early on that he'd never seen one in the wild. Dave even dropped us off in the inner harbor afterward (passing his dock in the process) so we wouldn't need to catch a cab back to the hotel.
In short, although they aren't in the inner harbor and are slightly more expensive, they are absolutely worth it if. I've been on good whale watching trips elsewhere, but this experience was much better.










