My wife and I made a prepaid reservation at the Sutton Place for 3 nights starting August 19, 2008, before we left on a cruise in the Inside Passage. We had booked a reservation months before our trip and had prepaid for our stay with a request that the hotel hold our rooms for late arrival as we planned to arrive around 10 pm on the first night. Our flight was delayed and when we arrived at midnight, the doorman said,
"I hope you have a reservation because we are sold out." The desk clerk told us we had no room and we would have to take a taxi and use another hotel. They gave us a voucher for the taxi, another room and breakfast for 3 days. They promised to refund the first night's charges, but we never received the refund. We were upgraded to a suite, but we had to change hotels and when we attempted to check in at noon the second day, we were told to come back later.
The taxi driver who took us to the other hotel said he had done the same for another guest an hour earlier.
It's obvious that the Sutton place overbooks its rooms even for prepaid guests. While the rooms are nice, their reservations are a disaster. While they attempted to make up for their mistake, we lost almost a day changing hotels.
My advice if you insist on staying at the Sutton Place, to either make sure you arrive in the afternoon, after check in or stay at the Sheraton up the street. Arriving at midnight to find your room has been given away shows an indifference to customers that is beyond contempt.











